“the arguments of those of us who hold that God is temporal boil down to two: we hold that a proper understanding of God’s action vis-à-vis the creation implies that God is temporal, and we hold that a proper understanding of God’s knowledge implies that God is temporal. In fact I think God’s temporality is also implied by the fact that God exists now, and existed yesterday, and will exist tomorrow; but in my experience, defenders of divine timelessness are not impressed with this argument—though why not has never been clear to me.”